Fears grow that EU Clean Air proposals could be scrapped

Rumours circulate in Brussels that Commission President Juncker and Vice President Timmermans could scrap proposed air quality legislation

Fears are growing among politicians and air quality campaigners that the proposed Clean Air Package of proposed EU legislation could be scrapped, amid rumours that the proposals will not be on the European Commission’s agenda for 2015.

Developed by the previous Commission under the stewardship of former Environment Commissioner Janez Potocnik in 2013, the Clean Air Package includes proposals to tackle emissions at source and for Member States to meet stricter pollution limits (see story).

The European Commission’s Clean Air Package may be scrapped, sources report

The European Commission’s Clean Air Package may be scrapped, sources report

However, new Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker signalled last month that the policy package would be reviewed by incoming Commissioners, prompting fears that the proposals could be scrapped altogether (see story).

Now, it is understood that President Juncker and First Vice President Frans Timmermans are meeting today (December 11) with chairmen of the political groups in the European Parliament in Brussels to discuss the Commission’s work schedule for 2015, which is expected to be officially announced next week.

And, sources in Brussels have indicated to that President Juncker and VP Timmermans may not include the Clean Air Package from the Commission’s 2015 work schedule, prompting UK politicians and campaigners to voice support for the proposals.


Rumours of a possible scrappage of the proposals yesterday led to the Labour Party’s environment spokesperson in Europe and MEP for London, Seb Dance, to comment that he was “extremely disappointed to hear renewed rumours that the Commission intends to drop both the air quality package and the circular economy package”.

Mr Dance, who is also shadow rapporteur for the National Emissions Ceiling (NEC) Directive, added: “Air pollution is a massive problem across Europe not least in my constituency of London. Only this week a report put deaths related to air quality at 29,000 in the UK per year – and the government continues to miss the existing EU targets.

“The EU has always led the way on reducing emissions and now is not the time to stray from that. The Labour Party will use every means at our disposal to represent the importance of these packages to President Junker.”

Paul Brennan, Labour MEP for North East England, echoed Mr Dance’s comments, describing the Clean Air Package as “essential for healthy lives”.

Thus, Mr Brennan said, scrapping the proposals would be “Very disappointing if true, especially when lead MEPs are all at Lima [for the global climate change conference]”.

Lib Dems

Meanwhile, Liberal Democrat MEP for South East England, Catherine Bearder, said yesterday that the EU “must strengthen air quality targets, not weaken them, so that we can tackle the sources of pollution both at home and abroad”.

She added: “Many of the pollutants that end up in the air we breathe originate from the continent. We need stricter, clearer EU limits in order for all European governments to take coordinated action and clean up Europe’s air.”

It is also understood that Green Party MEP for South East England, Keith Taylor — who has been an advocate of the Clean Air package — is considering launching a petition urging the Commission to put the air quality legislation on the agenda for 2015.

In addition, campaign group ClientEarth — which took the UK government to court over its failure to meet EU nitrogen dioxide limits — said that dropping the Clean Air Package “would be a devastating move”.

Clean Air in London

It was estimated when the Clean Air package was first announced that the proposals would save 58,000 premature deaths each year in Europe with a cost benefit of around 40-140 billion euros each year after 2030.

Simon Birkett, founder and director of campaign group Clean Air in London (CAL), told this morning (December 11) that scrapping the proposals would be “catastrophic for everyone everywhere”; adding that doing so “would sentence more than 50,000 people to early death”.

Mr Birkett also voiced concern that no UK government ministers had signed a letter sent last week (December 1) urging the Commission to maintain the Clean Air and Circular Economy packages on the 2015 agenda, despite the letter being signed by a number of environment and energy ministers from the likes of France, Germany, Belgium, Spain, Italy and Sweden.

However, he said that following the Environmental Audit Committee’s high profile air quality report this week (see story) the media was now regularly following air quality as a new item, which could help increase UK public support for maintaining the Clean Air Package.

Mr Birkett said: “Every time another report is published the public’s understanding of the issue cranks up a notch.”


Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Joe Cox
Joe Cox
9 years ago

No mention of Keith Taylor and the Green Party Lobby’s good work to keep the package working.

9 years ago

Good. Because it’s a load of energy lobby brand manipulated propaganda.

Help us break the news – share your information, opinion or analysis
Back to top